COP29: black people are in ‘racial sacrifice zones’

By Pedro Borges
TranslationJuliana Winkel
Share:

Letícia Leobet, international advisor at Geledés Instituto da Mulher Negra, follows the negotiations of the Climate Conference for the second year, this time in Baku, Azerbaijan. She explains the strategies used to ensure that the world recognizes the role of Afro-descendants in preserving the planet.

By Pedro Borges / Translation by Juliana Winkel

–

Baku – One of the central parts of the Climate Change Conference (COP) is the negotiations between countries, whether to define goals, agreements, or even to pressure for a specific measure to be implemented. Among the Brazilians who follow these dialogues is activist Letícia Leobet, international advisor at Geledés Instituto da Mulher Negra.

Leobet’s statements were also made in June in Bonn, Germany, which functions as a pre-COP and brings together diplomats from various countries as a way of continuing the issues and agreements that will be discussed during the COP. Due to the smaller number of participants, there is the possibility of building a closer dialogue with diplomats and even with civil society agents from other countries.

Geledés Instituto da Mulher Negra presented a letter of recommendations to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). In the document, the organization presents the concept of Racial Sacrifice Zones, an idea that racism determines regions that will suffer more acutely from climate change and that black people are more present in these areas.

“The Afro-descendant population is disproportionately concentrated in global sacrifice zones – regions that have become dangerous and even uninhabitable due to environmental degradation. These areas can be more appropriately described as “racial sacrifice zones” because they largely encompass the ancestral lands of indigenous peoples, as well as black and peripheral territories that have faced the worst impacts of climate change, which intensifies the need for climate adaptation measures that consider racial and territorial inequalities,” the text says.

Geledés is also preparing to organize a preparatory meeting for COP30, which will take place in Belém, Brazil, next year. The meeting of the Black Women’s Institute is scheduled to take place in May 2025 and will be an opportunity to discuss with Itamaraty about Brazil’s strategies for the meeting.

In view of the increasing impact of climate change, such as floods in Rio Grande do Sul and droughts in rivers in the northern region of the country, the activist still believes that the Brazilian government and other nations are being hypocritical in dealing with the problem.

“There is a promise regarding the adoption of effective climate policies, but we cannot see this narrative being realized in the actual adoption of these policies. And there is a loss of credibility in a country that has tried to position itself as a reference in terms of tackling climate change and that, on the other hand, has witnessed and experienced situations like Rio Grande do Sul and others in its territory,” she explains.

(Vinicius Martins/Alma Preta)

In an interview with Alma Preta, Letícia Leobet detailed the concept of “racial sacrifice zones” and spoke about the strategies used so that Brazil can recognize Afro-descendants as protectors of the environment, as well as about the ways to pressure the country to become an effective global leader.

Check out the full interview

Alma Preta: What are Geledés’ strategies for influencing this space?

Letícia Leobet: One of our main strategies with Brazilian diplomacy has been to send recommendations. So we do a complete analysis of the documents that are being negotiated at the COP, of the main discussions that are taking place. And we send these recommendations to Itamaraty, as well as to the executive branch and the ministries that are involved in the process.

AP: What feedback did you receive after sending the recommendations?

LL: We did not receive direct feedback, an email response or anything like that, but this has strengthened our dialogue with Itamaraty. We recently participated in a conversation that Itamaraty held with civil society – and we asked the Brazilian State what strategies they are using to include these demands that we presented.

AP: Last year, you followed the negotiation spaces as an observer. Do you continue with the same strategy?

LL: We follow the same strategy. Last year, I think there was a different issue, which was the fact that we were getting closer to Brazilian diplomacy. It was our first contact.

This year, we have something different from last year, which is the fact that we participated in Bonn, in Germany. Bonn is the pre-conference, pre-COP, as we call it. And it also gives us an even more intense, closer face-to-face with Brazilian diplomacy.

We also use these recommendations to coordinate with civil society organizations in other countries and to support the diplomacy of other countries.

AP: Do you believe that the possibility of more concrete influence is through this behind-the-scenes work with Brazilian diplomacy?

LL: That’s right. Basically, what we try to do is to include language. What we want is for issues that will respond to the racial agenda to be represented in the negotiation documents.

A very concrete example: if we are talking about global adaptation indicators, then our concern is how these indicators will address issues of race, gender and territory.

To give a very behind-the-scenes example, at COP28 (and this is largely based on the relationship we have been building with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs), the diplomat who was negotiating signaled to us the opportunity to make a proposal for a text. ‘This is the text, what do you suggest?’. And then we included in the language what we considered to be important: issues of race, issues related to the Afro-descendant community. We sent it and he went there and made the proposal.

AP: And how is the work of monitoring the negotiations like? What is the dynamics of the negotiations?

LL: The basis of the negotiations is a text. There is a text prepared by the facilitators of that agenda. So, for example, in the gender agenda, one of the facilitators is from the Democratic Republic of Congo and the other is from Norway. They prepare a base text, an initial text, and offer it to the member states, so that they can make their recommendations based on this initial text.

Or not, the opposite, which is what we see happening most, which is rejecting the language. And then the negotiation process comes in regarding this language. There are many things related to implementation issues, there are many new things, there are things that are discussed in the context of financing, there are things that are discussed in the context of the countries’ responsibility in relation to the issue of emissions, or the issue of financing.

AP: What are your expectations for this year’s negotiations, even from what you have already seen in Bonn?

LL: The scenario we have is extremely delicate. My impression is that everything is still very abstract. The definition of this new financing value and the criteria behind it, which will be the main discussion on financing, is all very uncertain.

And it is a concrete area in terms of influencing all the other agendas. Financing will influence adaptation, it will influence the just transition.

AP: How has Geledés, and perhaps other black organizations, been looking at COP30 in Belém, Brazil?

LL: Brazilian diplomacy has even looked at civil society and said, ‘calm down, let’s first go through COP29 and then we’ll go to COP30’. But we know that’s not the case and that many negotiations certainly need to be made right now.

Geledés is organizing a pre-COP event, which will take place in May 2025, which will be precisely a high-level event to organize negotiations with UN representatives, diplomacy from several signatory countries, civil society, and other actors that are relevant in this process for us to discuss. And I think that one of these discussions is precisely how Brazil intends to position itself.

I think there is a very important point about this, that although it is a COP in Brazil, it is a COP for Latin America and a COP for the Global South, which brings the opportunity to voice the demands, specificities and alternative solutions thought of from the Global South, thought of from Latin America.

AP: You coined a term in the documents of the UN called racial sacrifice zones. What are these areas?

LL: Racial sacrifice zones are a way of highlighting environmental racism. So, we are talking specifically about territories occupied by historically vulnerable populations, historically discriminated against and that end up becoming zones in which, based on the dimension of climate change, these communities will be impacted in a specific way, differently.

So, the use of this concept of racial sacrifice zone is very much linked to this idea of ​​making the concept of environmental racism visible and making explicit these disparities with regard to the impact of climate change.

And this concept also brings some tension to the perspective of climate justice based on the need to incorporate racial justice. We have emphasized that there is no climate justice without racial justice, without gender justice.

Share:

Deixe um comentário

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

plugins premium WordPress