Why do authoritarian leaders take power in some countries? How can one recognize a dictator before they reach power? What strategies can be used to stop the rise of leaders who might build an authoritarian regime and thus protect democracy?
Harvard political scientists Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt, in their book How Democracies Die (2018), analyze how authoritarian and populist leaders rise to power and undermine democratic systems.
Devil’s alliances between political parties and authoritarian figures
In 1924, in Italy, King Victor Emmanuel III appointed Benito Mussolini as prime minister after the March on Rome, believing that a charismatic and popular leader was needed during a time of crisis. In Germany in 1933, the President of the German Republic, Paul von Hindenburg, appointed Hitler as chancellor, trusting that his broad popular support could be controlled by other political forces.
In 1992, in Venezuela—considered the oldest democracy in South America since 1958—former President Rafael Caldera embraced the cause of Hugo Chávez, a military leader of the rebel group “Bolivars,” who had just attempted a coup. This decision boosted Caldera’s popular support but also gave credibility to Chávez. When, in 1994, Caldera dropped all charges and released him from prison, he literally opened the doors for Chávez to rise to power and gradually dismantle democracy in Venezuela.
All three cases share a common denominator: during times of crisis and public discontent, major parties and political figures formed alliances with charismatic, populist outsiders, harshly critical of the status quo. The idea was to channel their reformist and populist energy to serve their own political goals. But as Levitsky and Ziblatt write, “This kind of devil’s bargain often backfires, as alliances provide outsiders with enough legitimacy to become serious contenders for power.”
Why do rebellious leaders rise to power and become dictators?
It’s often said that citizens get the government they deserve, implying that voters are to blame for the rise of authoritarian regimes. However, this theory assumes an overly idealized view of democracy, where citizens can easily choose or change their government based on personal interest.
In Europe’s historical authoritarian regimes, large political majorities initially opposed the rise of leaders like Hitler and Mussolini. “Potential demagogues exist in all democracies,” argue Levitsky and Ziblatt. “Although popular responses to extremist appeals matter, what matters more is whether political elites—especially parties—act as gatekeepers. Simply put, political parties are democracy’s gatekeepers.”
How to keep a dictator from gaining power?
First, they must be identified. Populist leaders rarely reveal their authoritarian ambitions before reaching office. Juan Linz, professor emeritus of Political Science at Yale University, outlined four warning signs in his book The Breakdown of Democratic Regimes (1978) to spot antidemocratic politicians:
- Rejection of democratic rules, either in words or actions
- Denial of the legitimacy of political opponents
- Tolerance or encouragement of violence
- A willingness to limit civil liberties of opponents, including the media
These are often populist outsiders—anti-system politicians who claim to be “the voice of the people,” attack the corrupt elite, and once elected, attack democratic institutions.
Once identified, it is the responsibility of political parties and their leaders—as democracy’s gatekeepers—to expose their lies and stop their rise. First, extremist forces must be systematically isolated, delegitimized, and defeated by democratic parties. This includes eliminating extremism within their own ranks. A symbolic example is the Swedish Conservative Party in the 1920s–30s, which expelled its increasingly radical and Nazi-sympathizing youth wing.
Moreover, democratic parties must avoid any alliance with antidemocratic candidates or parties. When extremists do enter the electoral competition, democratic parties must form a united front to defend democracy. This happened in Austria during the 2016 elections, when leaders from the center-right Österreichische Volkspartei (Austrian People’s Party) supported Green candidate Alexander Van der Bellen, who successfully defeated Norbert Hofer, the far-right candidate of the Freedom Party of Austria.
Conclusion: the cure to protect democracy
As Levitsky and Ziblatt stress, political parties play a fundamental role in defending democratic systems and citizens from authoritarian threats. But democracy is also a system of rights and duties that benefits the people. So how can we protect it?
By not falling for populist rhetoric. By expressing our voices without waiting for the next election. By holding politicians accountable through protests and petitions. By voting when it’s time. By using the tools guaranteed by our Constitution to take part in our country’s political life.
Democracy is not just a political game among parties—it’s the framework that safeguards our freedoms, our participation, and our ability to shape both present and future as individuals and as a society.
