A “Crisis” that Dehumanizes: The Reality of Migration in the European Union

By Carolina Picot
Mentorship Angela Nardelli
Translation Sofia Lima
Share:
Is the migration “crisis” in the EU really a crisis? Who does it really affect? A look at how public perception of migration has changed.

By Carolina Picot
Mentor: Angela Nardelli

Although 2015 was neither the first nor the last year of large-scale migration, it undoubtedly marked a turning point in public perception of migration and in European policies. This raises important questions: was it truly a “migration crisis”? A “crisis” for whom? For people fleeing war and persecution? For European governments unable to manage their reception systems? Or for the very idea of an Europe that believed itself immune to migration? Most importantly, after ten years, how do we interpret this “crisis”?

A crisis or a failure of migration policies?
The term “crisis” suggests a sudden and unpredictable event, yet the conflicts and humanitarian emergencies in Syria, Afghanistan, Eritrea, South Sudan, and Nigeria had been ongoing for a long time, well known as situations that threaten the lives of millions of civilians. Some academics define the so-called “migrant crisis”, “migration crisis”, “refugee crisis” or “Europe’s border crisis” as a consequence of conflicts, wars, and neocolonial occupations in which European powers are involved.

This challenges the dominant narrative that treats migration as an “external” phenomenon to European stability, ignoring its connection to global dynamics in which Europe plays a key role. Although the use of the term “crisis” is widely criticized, it is important to reflect on the practical challenges faced by frontline EU countries, including Italy and Greece, whose reception systems were quickly overwhelmed by the number of arrivals and by bureaucratic obstacles in processing applications for international and asylum protection. Added to this is the difficulty of member states aligning on a coherent, yet humane and effective, approach.

The Italian case
In Italy, the management of migration and borders has followed the same approach since the 1970s: migration has first been politicized and then framed as a security emergency. The entire system rests on three pillars: emergency, security, and criminality. The idea of a migratory “invasion”, reinforced by rhetoric around “ethnic replacement”, feeds the perception of a constant state of emergency.

Refugees are also subjected to media discourse portraying them as a “threat”, legitimizing security measures such as the introduction of the crime of irregular stay in 2009, the tightening of border controls, and the use of administrative detention. Finally, the third pillar is evident in the criminalization of NGOs operating in the Mediterranean to save lives, turning solidarity into an act under accusation. Framing migration as a security problem leads to serious human rights violations and amplifies migrants’ vulnerabilities and mechanisms of exclusion.

Can these policies truly be considered effective? Or are we witnessing a political failure that has not only failed to resolve the “crisis” but has fueled it, ignoring root causes and sacrificing fundamental rights in the name of security and control? What is certain is that reducing migration to an issue of security and flow control sidelines its human dimension, pushing policies towards solutions that disregard the dignity and basic rights of individuals. A clear example, ten years after the start of the “crisis”, is the inefficiency of return hubs, including the one in Albania.

A narrative that dehumanizes
The construction of the “migration crisis” has not been limited to political choices but has also deeply influenced how migrants are represented in the media and perceived by the public. The use of numbers, statistics, and abstract categories has often obscured individual stories, reinforcing a narrative that renders migrants as anonymous, faceless figures.

Among the political elements of this crisis, we find the dehumanization of migrants. What does it mean to dehumanize? It is a mechanism that makes it easier to justify violence and hostility towards another group. In this context, migrants are often portrayed as an “Other” devoid of emotions, hopes, and fears, or reduced to numbers and abstract categories such as “illegal immigrants” or “economic migrants”. This process has a dual impact: on one hand, it fosters indifference towards the lived experience and suffering of these individuals, and on the other, it justifies policies that ignore their fundamental rights, as seen in the treatment of refugees and migrants at Europe’s borders.

When dehumanization has a face: from reception to refugee camps
There are, however, moments when this narrative cracks. In September 2015, the image of Alan Kurdi, the three-year-old Syrian boy found lifeless on a Turkish beach, challenged this dehumanization. For a brief moment, the public debate was not about numbers or threats, but about a human tragedy involving innocent lives.

Yet while the image prompted governments and citizens to question migration management, it did not bring about structural change in European policies. On the contrary, in 2016 the European Union signed an agreement with Turkey, outsourcing border control and making it even harder for people fleeing war and persecution to access protection. This pattern has repeated itself multiple times: public outrage followed by even more restrictive measures, as seen in pushback policies in the Mediterranean and the criminalization of NGOs saving lives at sea.

Dehumanization is further exacerbated in refugee camps, where, beyond material deprivation, there is a lack of connection to both the country of origin and the host country. These are emergency solutions conceived as temporary, yet still in place a decade later. In many camps, conditions were (as in the case of Moria) or still are (as in Calais) unacceptable. Running water and electricity are often absent, and access to food is not guaranteed. Camps are overcrowded, sanitation facilities inadequate, and poor hygiene conditions along with limited access to clean drinking water increase the risk of epidemics. In addition to physical consequences, the mental health of displaced people is also at risk.

Ten years later, can we truly say that Europe has found a solution to the “migration crisis” of 2015? Security policies and migration flow control have not solved the situation, but rather have fueled it, sacrificing the dignity and fundamental rights of migrants. If the rhetoric of “crisis” continues to justify increasingly restrictive measures, perhaps it is time to reconsider European migration policies and give priority to protection and human rights rather than to security and dehumanization.

Share:

Deixe um comentário

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *

plugins premium WordPress